Menu ☰
Liverpool Pals header
Search Pals

Search
Capt Arthur de Bells Adam (MC)
1885 - 1916


CPL David Wallace Crawford
1887 - 1916


Lce-Corpl John Joseph Nickle
1894 - 1916


Pte 17911 Morton Neill
1897 - 1916


Lieut Edward Stanley Ashcroft
1883 - 1918
Lieut Edward Stanley Ashcroft

Pte 35940 George Munro Watson (served as John Graham)


  • Age: 17
  • From: Liverpool
  • Regiment: The King's (Liverpool Regiment) 18th Btn
  • K.I.A Monday 11th September 1916
  • Commemorated at: Gorre Brit Cem, Beuvry
    Panel Ref: III.A.9
Mystery surrounds this soldier.  SDGW shows George enlisted in Liverpool under the name John Graham, and also shows place of birth as Liverpool. However, the only George M. Watson born in the Liverpool area between 1870-1902 died in infancy.  After exhaustive research George M. Watson, alias John Graham, appears to be this man. We would greatly appreciate any conflicting or supporting evidence.

George Munro Watson was born in Inverness on 17th December 1898, the second of four sons born to William John Ross Watson and his wife Isabella Christina (née Munro). Both his parents were from Ross-shire and were married on 17th July 1895 in Brooklyn, New York, USA.. Their children were born in Inverness. George had an older brother, Hugh, born in 1897, and younger brother William, born in 1900.  His father had graduated from Oxford and was the Rector of Inverness Academy at a young age. 
 
In 1901 William and Isabella (Ella) are living at Oak Dale, Broadstone Park, Inverness. His father, 36, is a headmaster, his mother Ella is 32, Hugh is 3, George 2, and William is 7 months old. Also in the household are a domestic servant and a children’s nurse. Their youngest child Alastair was born in September 1902.  Five days after his birth his mother Ella died of childbirth fever, at the age of 33.  George was three years old.
 
His father remarried to Elizabeth Catherine Carmichael in 1906.  They had two sons, Alexander Carmichael Watson, born in 1908 and James Carmichael Watson, in 1910. Sadly, Alexander died at the age of 15 in 1923. 
 
From 1909 to 1914 his father was the Rector of the Edinburgh Royal High School, where George was a pupil. He then became Chair of Celtic Languages, Literature, History, and Antiquities at the University of Edinburgh. Unfortunately the 1911 census is not available.
 
SDGW shows that George enlisted in Liverpool as John Graham, Private 35940, 18th (Pals) Battalion of The King’s Liverpool Regiment. George ran away to join the Army in 1915, but his parents managed to get him discharged as under age. He was obviously a determined character, and he went all the way to Liverpool and enlisted under an assumed name, so that his parents wouldn’t be able to track him down. Unfortunately his military record has not survived, so the details are not known. George survived the deadly days of July 1916 on the Somme, including the attack on Montauban, and the murderous fighting in Trones Wood. At the beginning of August the battalion entrains for Abbeville for rest and reorganisation, and on the 11th re-enters the front line around Givenchy.

From the battalion War Diary: 

03/9/1916 – Battalion moved to Hingette.

08/9/1916 – Battalion moved to Gorre into Brigade Reserve.

09/9/1916 to 11/9/1916  – Battalion provides working parties in front line. One casualty wounded on 10/9/1916, one KIA on 11/9/1916.  Pte 35940 John Graham (attached 254th Tunnelling) was killed in action.  He was just 17 years old.

George now rests in Gorre British and Indian Cemetery, Beuvry. 

The chateau at Gorre was occupied early in the war by troops serving with the British Expeditionary Force and the Indian Corps, and the cemeteries, located in the south-east corner of original the chateau grounds, were begun in the autumn of 1914. The Indian section of the cemetery was closed in October 1915, shortly before the Indian infantry divisions left France for redeployment to the Middle East.

Many of those who now lie in plots V and VI of the British section of the cemetery were killed during the Battle of Estaires in April 1918. There are now over 930 Commonwealth servicemen of the First World War buried or commemorated here. The cemetery, which was designed by Charles Holden, also contains nine war graves of other nationalities, most of them German.

The chateau at Gorre was occupied early in the war by troops serving with the British Expeditionary Force and the Indian Corps, and the cemeteries, located in the south-east corner of original the chateau grounds, were begun in the autumn of 1914. The Indian section of the cemetery was closed in October 1915, shortly before the Indian infantry divisions left France for redeployment to the Middle East.

Many of those who now lie in plots V and VI of the British section of the cemetery were killed during the Battle of Estaires in April 1918. There are now over 930 Commonwealth servicemen of the First World War buried or commemorated here. The cemetery, which was designed by Charles Holden, also contains nine war graves of other nationalities, most of them German.

Gorre Chateau during the First World War

For much of the war, the chateau stood approximately four kilometres behind a section of the British front-line that ran northward along the Aubers Ridge from Givenchy-lès-la-Bassée to Festubert. From the end of the Battle of Festubert in May 1915 until the spring of 1918, this was considered a relatively ‘quiet’ sector. The village of Gorre was occasionally bombarded by German artillery during this period, but the chateau remained intact and its rooms were used as an officer’s mess and headquarters for British units stationed in the area. The grounds of the chateau were also the site of several artillery emplacements, a rifle range and an improvised parade ground and football pitch. Throughout 1916 and ’17 British troops could be seen drilling in the fields next to the chateau or unloading supplies from barges on the La Bassée Canal, which runs just south of the village.

The British section of the cemetery was used by infantry and artillery units stationed in the area until April 1918, when the relative quiet of the sector was shattered by the German Spring Offensive and Gorre became a support post close behind the front line during the Battle of Estaire. This battle was one of two massive German assaults on the Commonwealth positions from Ypres to Festubert that became known as the Battle of the Lys. When the battle erupted on 9 April, the 55th (West Lancashire) Division occupied the front-line trenches running north from Givenchy to Richebourg L’Avoué. The Allied positions to their left, around the village of Le Touret, were held by Portuguese units.

After a preliminary artillery bombardment that began on the evening of 7 April the German Sixth Army, spearheaded by storm troops, attacked in force early on the morning of the 9th. Heavy mist enabled the attackers to get very close to the Allied lines before they were observed and Portuguese units suffered heavy casualties and began to retire. Further south, the various formations of the 55th Division were hard pressed from the outset and the front line trenches around Givenchy were the scene of fierce fighting between British and German troops. The divisional brigade holding the northern section of the British line was forced to pull back, but well-organised counter-attacks and determined defence elsewhere enabled the 55th Division to hold its ground for the rest of the battle and prevent a major German breakthrough. Fighting continued in the trenches east of Gorre until 17 April when the German forces finally broke off the attack. In just over a week of fighting almost 3,000 officers and men of the Division had been killed, wounded, or taken prisoner, but the territory over which they had fought remained in Allied hands.

The Inverness Royal Academy produced a magazine “The Academical” which contained obituaries of war casualties, and here is what they wrote about George in 1917.

The Late Pte. GEORGE M. WATSON.
10th September 1916.

Private George Munro Watson, second son of Dr. W.J. Watson, for many years Rector of the Academy, and now Professor of Celtic Language and Literature at Edinburgh University, was killed instantaneously by a sniper on the afternoon of 10th September 1916. His officer says in a letter that he was the keenest of soldiers, and much regretted by all who knew him. Pte. Watson would not have been 18 till last December, but his sense of patriotism was very strong, and in June 1915 he joined the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders at the age of 16. Thereafter he joined the Royal Liverpool Rifles, and went to France in the middle of July last year. For a few weeks prior to his death he was on duty with a Tunnelling Company of the Royal Engineers. He was educated at the Academy and the Royal High School of Edinburgh. 

CWGC communicated with H. Watson Esq., of 8 Spence Street, Edinburgh (probably George’s  brother Hugh) to erect his headstone. George’s effects went to Kenneth F Carmichael (possibly his step-mother’s brother).
 
His father became a highly respected and published scholar and when he resigned his Chair in 1938 was succeeded in the position by his son James Carmichael Watson, George’s half brother.
 
James Carmichael Watson enlisted in the Royal Navy in WW2 as an Ordinary Seaman, despite being eligible for an exemption.  In The Scotsman, on 6th April 1942: “Reported missing, presumed killed, Ordinary Seaman James Carmichael Watson, Professor of Celtic Languages, Literature, History, and Antiquities in the University of Edinburgh, youngest son of Emeritus Professor, W. J. Watson, and grandson of the late Alexander Carmichael, LL.D.”  James was killed when H.M.S. Jaguar was sunk by a U-boat off Egypt in March 1942. James is remembered on Plymouth Naval Memorial. He was 33.
 
When his father died in 1948, he warranted a column-length obituary in The Scotsman. James Carmichael and his three other sons (who would have been George’s three full brothers) are mentioned. There is no mention of George.
 
George Munro Watson is commemorated on the following Memorials -

Royal High School Porch Memorial, Edinburgh 

Highland Tolbooth Church, Greyfriars Lothian Memorial, 

The Men and Women of the Burgh and Parish of Inverness Roll of Honour 

We are very grateful to Steve Savage who has provided further family information on the Watson family below, as well as providing the marriage details for George's parents and the article contained in "The Academical". 

The H. Watson who dealt with the war graves people was undoubtedly my grandfather Hugh Watson. He had joined the  Cameron Highlanders in 1915. Later on he was attached to the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders during the war, and saw service in the Salonica campaign. He went on to be a lawyer, and among things became President of the Scottish Law Society and was knighted. He never spoke to me about George, or about James Carmichael Watson for that matter, and when I (aged eleven or twelve) asked him what the First World War had been like, he would not be drawn, and would only say that war was a horrible thing and he just hoped I’d never have to go to war. I later found out that his battalion was awarded a collective Croix de Guerre with bronze palm by the French after an action at Doiran late in the war.

My grandmother’s only brother was also killed in France in September 1916 - he was in the Royal Scots, but I have noticed that the war graves documentation says he was attached to 5/Liverpools at the time of his death, and I know from my mother that for many years my grandparents used to go to Liverpool annually to visit one of his comrades.

My only other Liverpool connection is that I myself was born at the maternity hospital in Liverpool 8 ... but I was soon whisked off up north to Yorkshire and then Scotland.

We currently have no further information on George Munro Watson, If you have or know someone who may be able to add to the history of this soldier, please contact us.

 

Killed On This Day.

(109 Years this day)
Sunday 29th October 1916.
Cpl 33019 Arthur Moses Hotson
32 years old

(109 Years this day)
Sunday 29th October 1916.
L/Cpl 22457 John Cecil Lines (MM)
25 years old

(108 Years this day)
Monday 29th October 1917.
Pte 21428 Frank Rouse
22 years old

(107 Years this day)
Tuesday 29th October 1918.
2nd Lieutenant Harry Todd
27 years old